Happy Birthday, You Mysterious Bastard

September 30th, Truman Capote

Truman Garcia Capote (Truman Streckfus Persons),
September 30th, 1924.

In the middle years of the 20th Century, America produced three works that changed the literary landscape of the English language. Catch-22, To Kill a Mockingbird, and In Cold Blood, all landed like hand grenades on the scene and were notable because their authors would never quite produce anything of such brilliance during the rest of their careers. When an interviewer once remarked to Joseph Heller that he had never written anything quite as good as Catch-22 since, he replied, with some justification, "Well, who has?"

The other two authors, Harper Lee and Truman Capote, respectively, would also never go on to produce anything quite as good, and it was fitting that they became close friends. But it was Capote's In Cold Blood that was the only one of the three works that almost single-handedly invented an entirely new literary genre. In Cold Blood is one of those books that everyone owns, but not everyone has ever read. Even the cover has become a classic of mid-century graphic design. But everyone should read it. It's a remarkable work of literary art if, well, it treats the veracity of some of the events with a little of the extravagance for which the author became known in his personal life. In tapping into the morbid fascination for events that keep us fascinated in Jack the Ripper and listening to true-life crime podcasts and marrying it with one of the 20th century's finest compilers of narrative structure, Capote composed something that might, at times, have a factual glint in its eye, but is brilliant nonetheless.

Truman Capote was born on September 30, 1924, in New Orleans, Louisiana, to a turbulent household. His father, Archulus Persons, was a conman and gambler, while his mother, Lillie Mae Faulk, had aspirations for a more glamorous life. When Capote was just four, his parents separated, and he was sent to live with relatives in Monroeville, Alabama. During his time there, he formed a close friendship with his neighbour, Harper Lee, who would later go on to write the Pulitzer Prize-winning novel To Kill a Mockingbird. Lee and Capote maintained a lifelong friendship, and she would famously base the character Dill on him in her novel.

From a young age, Capote exhibited an intense interest in writing. By the time he was 11, he claimed to have written a full-length novel. His unusual upbringing and early encounters with isolation fueled his creativity, and he later described himself as being “different” from other children. Capote's personal identity became an integral part of his work, as his flamboyant personality and open homosexuality made him both a subject of fascination and a social outsider in mid-20th century America.

Capote’s early adulthood was spent in New York City, where his career as a writer took off. He published his first novel, Other Voices, Other Rooms, in 1948 when he was just 23. The novel was semi-autobiographical, touching on themes of isolation and personal identity, and was an instant success. Capote’s provocative writing style, combined with his knack for crafting compelling characters, garnered him literary acclaim.

In the 1950s, Capote further established his reputation with works such as The Grass Harp and the novella Breakfast at Tiffany’s. The latter became one of his most famous works, introducing the world to the iconic character of Holly Golightly. This character captured Capote’s fascination with social misfits, outsiders, and those who refused to conform to societal norms. Though the novella was adapted into a wildly successful film starring Audrey Hepburn, Capote was disappointed with the casting, as he had envisioned Marilyn Monroe in the role.

Despite his success, Capote longed to write something more significant, something that would transcend the boundaries of fiction. In 1959, Capote’s life would change dramatically when he came across a small newspaper article detailing the brutal murder of a Kansas farming family—the Clutters. Fascinated by the crime, Capote travelled to Holcomb, Kansas, with his childhood friend Harper Lee to investigate the case. What began as a straightforward journalistic endeavour turned into a six-year obsession, culminating in his masterpiece, In Cold Blood.

In Cold Blood, published in 1966, was a groundbreaking work that straddled the line between journalism and literature. Capote meticulously researched the Clutter family murders, conducted extensive interviews with residents of Holcomb, law enforcement officials, and even the murderers themselves, Richard Hickock and Perry Smith. The result was a new form of writing that Capote dubbed the “non-fiction novel,” in which real events were narrated with the stylistic flair of a novel.

The impact of In Cold Blood on both the literary world and society at large was profound. Capote’s portrayal of the brutal Clutter family murders combined the elements of investigative reporting with literary storytelling in a way that had never been seen before. His approach set a new standard for non-fiction writing by focusing on the psychological complexities of both the victims and their killers, highlighting how personal circumstances can lead individuals to commit heinous acts. This humanizing of murderers challenged readers to consider broader societal issues such as mental illness, poverty, and the criminal justice system. Capote’s intimate portrayal of Richard Hickock and Perry Smith blurred the line between villain and victim, pushing the public to grapple with their own preconceived notions of morality and justice.

The book’s immense popularity contributed to a wave of media interest in true crime stories, an interest that persists today. In many ways, In Cold Blood laid the foundation for what would become modern-day crime journalism, as well as the true crime genre seen in podcasts, documentaries, and television series. Capote's painstaking dedication to uncovering the nuances of the case showed the importance of not only reporting the facts but also delving into the motivations and psyche of the people involved. By doing so, Capote also raised ethical questions about the nature of storytelling—specifically, whether it was appropriate to use real-life tragedies for entertainment or artistic gain.

The ethical considerations surrounding In Cold Blood have sparked significant debates in both literary and journalistic circles. Critics questioned whether Capote manipulated certain details for dramatic effect, as some have pointed out discrepancies between the book and the actual events. For example, while Capote claimed that he achieved an unprecedented level of access to Hickock and Smith, some argue that his narrative style may have led him to exaggerate or even fabricate certain interactions. This raises questions about the reliability of his account and the responsibilities of writers working within the true crime genre.

Additionally, Capote’s close relationship with the murderers themselves has been viewed as both a strength and a flaw in his work. While his ability to gain the trust of the killers allowed him to write a compelling and intimate portrait of them, it also blurred the lines between journalist and participant. Some have argued that Capote’s emotional involvement in the case compromised his objectivity, particularly when it came to the executions of Hickock and Smith, which had a devastating emotional impact on him. Despite these controversies, In Cold Blood remains a landmark work in both literature and journalism, standing as a testament to Capote’s groundbreaking innovation in storytelling.

The book’s publication also had a tangible effect on how the criminal justice system and capital punishment were discussed in the United States. At the time, the death penalty was a widely accepted form of punishment, but Capote’s sensitive portrayal of the two killers—especially Perry Smith—prompted many to question whether the state-sanctioned execution of criminals was a morally justifiable act. The nuanced depiction of their troubled pasts and the psychological toll of their execution humanized them in a way that had rarely been seen in crime reporting up until that point. In Cold Blood stirred public sympathy for individuals who had otherwise been dismissed as irredeemable criminals, contributing to the ongoing debate surrounding capital punishment.

Despite the acclaim, the creation of In Cold Blood took an enormous toll on Capote’s mental health. The six years he spent researching and writing the book consumed him emotionally and psychologically. His close involvement with the killers, combined with the trauma of witnessing their executions, haunted him for the rest of his life. He later admitted that the emotional strain of the project left him unable to complete another significant work, stating that In Cold Blood had "drained" him of his creative energy. The success of the book, while it brought him fame and fortune, also marked the beginning of Capote’s personal and professional decline.

Following In Cold Blood, Capote became a frequent fixture on the social scene, mingling with celebrities and elite figures. He threw extravagant parties, most notably the Black and White Ball, in 1966, which became one of the most famous social events of the 20th century. However, as Capote’s fame grew, so did his personal struggles. He became increasingly dependent on drugs and alcohol, and his once-prolific writing output slowed to a crawl. While he published short stories and essays during this period, he was never able to complete another major work. His long-promised novel, Answered Prayers, remained unfinished at the time of his death, adding to the sense of a career unfulfilled.

Capote passed away on August 25, 1984, in Los Angeles at the age of 59, from liver disease complicated by drug use. Despite his tragic decline, Capote’s literary legacy endures. His innovative approach to narrative journalism continues to influence writers and journalists today. In particular, In Cold Blood remains a seminal text in both the true crime genre and American literature as a whole. Capote’s ability to capture the complexity of human behaviour, his blend of fact and fiction, and his fearless exploration of dark and unsettling themes all cement his status as one of the most influential writers of the 20th century.

Thanks for reading! To share this article, please click the button below. If you’d like to help us out by making a donation via Kofi, anything would be gratefully received! Click the donation button to help out. It accepts PayPal and all the usual sources. You’re welcome to read for free and to share as much as you like, but this is a full-time job now, so if anyone would like to help out, it would be really appreciated. There are paid subs, too, for which you get cool exclusive stuff (with more stuff coming soon!)

Hope you enjoyed the article. Thanks, everyone!