Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Perlot's avatar

Great post.

Do we see any examples of ideology and snobbishness trumping climate/physics in Roman elite building practices?

For instance, the Romans didn't like pants, but as the Romans went north, they gave in and adopted pants because climate is a thing.

In the villa context you mention local materials and heated floors. But were these villas actually well adapted to cold climates, or buildings adapted to the southern Mediterranean being jury-rigged to serve in England because that's what culture demanded?

Sod houses are well adapted to Scandinavia, for instance. Is the villa equally well adapted, or just posturing?

Expand full comment
bnjd's avatar

Two changes between the pre-industrial world into the modern world are the separation of workplace and residence, and the separation of production and consumption. The co-mingling of production and consumption is evident in the elite houses of Pompeii according to Wallace-Hadrill. I am only familiar with a few literary examples of Italian villas. It appears that Italian villas and Romano-British villas combined these functions, too.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts